The Controversy: Was It a Like-for-Like Replacement?
The debate over Harshit Rana replacing Shivam Dube as a concussion substitute during the 4th T20I between India and England resurfaced after the series concluded. Initially, India’s head coach Gautam Gambhir remained silent, but he finally addressed the controversy after the 5th T20I, leaving former England cricketer Kevin Pietersen without a comeback.
The incident sparked heated discussions after ICC match referee Javagal Srinath approved Rana as a concussion substitute for Dube. Critics, including Pietersen, questioned the fairness of the decision, arguing that Dube is primarily a batting all-rounder, whereas Rana is more of a bowling all-rounder.
Many believed allowing Rana as a replacement gave India an advantage, with Pietersen particularly vocal about his discontent. After the 4th T20I, he took to social media, stating:
“The concussion substitution debate is raging, and here’s my take—it was never a like-for-like replacement. The match referee should acknowledge the mistake, close the chapter, and let’s shift focus to another thrilling clash tonight.”
Despite the controversy, the ICC has remained silent, and Srinath continues to face scrutiny for his decision.
Gautam Gambhir’s Witty Response
After India’s emphatic win in the 5th T20I, where England collapsed for just 97 runs in 10.3 overs, Gambhir was finally asked about the issue. His response was both sharp and humorous.
With a smile, Gautam Gambhir’s stated on Star Sports:
“He would have bowled four overs for sure today.”
His comment mocked England’s frustration and highlighted the irony—Dube bowled exceptionally well in the final match, taking 2 wickets in 2 overs while conceding just 11 runs. Had the game lasted longer, he would have likely completed his full quota of 4 overs, reinforcing the argument that he wasn’t just a batting all-rounder but also a capable bowler.
Moving Forward
While the debate over the substitution rule continues, India’s dominant performance in the series overshadowed the controversy. As for Gambhir, his witty response ensured that Pietersen and England had little room for argument.
With the ICC yet to issue an official statement, the debate lingers, but for now, India has the last laugh.
Explore the latest in cricket and stay updated with all the action at Sportssutra.